Two years removed from the first semi-state championship trophy and trip to the state finals in program history, the Warsaw football team looked to defend Fisher Field from a red-hot Chesterton side with another trip to Lucas Oil Stadium on the line. From the jump, the Tigers played with an edge that their opponent struggled to match. Going up 14-0 early in the game was more than enough, as the orange and black captured their second ever semi-state title with a 46-21 victory.
“It’s really special. As I’ve said all season I’m so excited by the fact that their efforts and their commitments and everything that goes with it is being rewarded,” head coach Bart Curtis said after advancing to the state finals for the third time in his career. “There’s no guarantee that all of that work is going to produce wins. It’s so sweet for them.”
Curtis went on to cite the regular season finale, a 37-30 loss to a Northridge team that will also play for a state title next week, as a turning point for his group.
“We had a little bump in the road back on October 16th. We had a chance to take home some hardware and we didn’t,” he said. “At that point we had to refocus and get back up. We didn’t win a trophy on October 16th, but we’ve won trophies the last three Fridays.”
With those three trophies already secured, the Tigers will have a chance to play for the biggest one of all when they take on Indianapolis Cathedral in the 5A championship game next Saturday. Warsaw has more than a few players on this year’s team that suffered the heartbreak of losing to Decatur Central in 2024, and they are looking to finish the job this time.
“We have the blueprint this time around. We know what it’s like, we’ve been there before, we know how bright the lights are,” senior fullback Michael Schenck said. “It’s about playing our best football and getting the job done for a community that shows us so much love.”
Getting the ball to begin the game, Warsaw wasted no time at all setting the tone. Picking up right where they left off in last week’s regional game, the Tigers marched right down the field in four minutes to score the game’s first touchdown on a 33-yard house call by Michael Schenck. The Trojans began their first drive of the night with a nice run by fullback Sam Posavac, but from there, the home defense straightened out and came up with a pair of big tackles on passing plays to force a turnover on downs at midfield.
The rest of the opening quarter was dominated by Warsaw as well, as the home side possessed the ball for eight of the 12 minutes. As the second quarter began, the Tigers were in the middle of another methodical drive powered by the legs of Schenck. The big play on this trip into the end zone was a speed option to Brady Sauer, who got the edge and was tackled by his facemask just before the goal line. Rewarding the senior for doing most of the work to get them there, Schenck received the carry at the one, punching it in for his second score of the night to make it 14-0 with 10:34 until halftime.
“I might have been the guy scoring the touchdowns tonight but I give it all to my offensive line, Mark had great reads all night and my halfbacks were giving me great blocks,” the senior said. “They deserve the credit, I was just in the end zone.”
Needing to get something going offensively before things started to get out of hand, Chesterton got exactly that the second time they touched the ball. The Warsaw defense came up with a few big plays on this drive, but the visitors were able to make bigger ones when they needed them. Converting on two third downs, including a 3rd and 14, the Trojans put themselves on the board as quarterback Hunter Boyd connected with Max Soffin in the end zone to cut the lead in half with five minutes until the break.
Chesterton caught their opponents off guard on the ensuing kickoff, attempting an onside kick. It turned out to be the perfect time to do so, as the home side was not ready for it at all, as the ball bounced off a finger tip and into the arms of the kicking team. Getting right back out there, this time the Tiger D was up to the challenge, stuffing Boyd on a 4th and 1 keeper for the second turnover on downs of the night.
“One thing about defense is that it doesn’t matter where the ball is. If a mistake happens, it’s our job to come up with the stop,” senior linebacker Matthew Flores-Ortega said. “We were able to hold up. Our practice paid off and it felt so good to get that stop.”
It took less than 30 seconds for the orange and black to take advantage, as on the very first play from scrimmage, Sauer broke loose on a counter play, outracing the Trojan secondary on his way to a 67-yard score to make it a two-touchdown game once more. That wouldn’t be the final possession of the first half for the home side, as the defense continued to lead the way with a third fourth down stop after the score. Time was the home side’s biggest enemy here, as the two minutes left on the clock were not enough to reach the end zone for a fourth time. Instead, John Conley came in and barely sneaked in a 37-yard field goal as time expired to make it a 24-7 game.
After putting together a great first half, the Warsaw defense came up with its biggest play yet just 20 seconds into the third quarter. With Posavac trying to fight through contact to pick up second extra yardage, the ball was punched out and recovered for a turnover. A few plays later, Schenck made it a hat trick with a 23-yard run that finally blew things wide open.
“It’s hard to imagine where we were in August when I look at us now. November in Indiana is a special thing. A lot of things have to line up and for this group they have,” Curtis said. “We’re tackling a lot better, we’re playing better on the offensive line. This is a group that has had the option to either buck up or lay down when faced with adverse situations, and they’ve shown how resilient they are every time.”
With a large deficit to overcome, the Trojans put together their second impressive drive of the night as Boyd was able to connect with his receivers to keep the chains moving. Eventually, the junior quarterback made a very impressive throw to Bradley Robinson while rolling to his left, which was good for a 23-yard touchdown. Still trailing by three scores, the visitors had burned five minutes to get that one.
Now it was the Tigers’ turn to play keep away, something they’ve been so good at all season long. This drive was no different, as the home side burned seven minutes off the clock on a drive that was punctuated by a six-yard run by Mark Haynes that made it 38-13 with nine and a half minutes remaining. On the first play of the ensuing Trojan drive, an underthrown ball by Boyd resulted in an interception by Nolan Himes led to another quick score. After a 30-yard carry by Wyatt Harman, Sauer finished things off with a 10-yard score that put things on ice, 46-13.
Chesterton went on to score one last touchdown to give the game its final score. The Tigers ran out the clock with a kneel down to the sound of thunderous applause from the Lake City faithful.
The 5A state championship game between Warsaw (12-1) and Indianapolis Cathedral will be played at 7 p.m. next Saturday at Lucas Oil Stadium.
“This team’s battle cry this month has been ‘one more Monday.’ Now, we’re going to get one last Monday together,” Curtis said with a smile on his face.