Eagle with Stars and Stripes
Continuously serving Kosciusko County since 1854

County Council Declines Having Their Own Attorney, For Now

Posted

Ed Ormsby serves as the attorney for the county, but the Kosciusko County Council discussed Thursday night whether they need to have their own as he’s the commissioners’ attorney if ever there is a conflict between the two elected boards.
No action or motions were taken.
In introducing the topic, Council President Tony Ciriello explained, “It was asked to be brought before the council to talk about the potential of the county getting their own attorney for the council. Dave (Wolkins) also requested from the auditor’s office a list of money that we spend on legal fees.”
The legal fees provided to the council go back from December 2024 through November 2026. Ciriello said the end of last year and this year was a bigger year for attorney fees because the council dealt with the Syracuse Public Library “stuff,” a new tax abatement policy put in place, wages for probation, the Municipal Unit Strategic Taskforce (MUST) meeting “and every little bit adds up.”
He said they are getting charged “fairly.” Ormsby’s current rate for Kosciusko County is $280 per hour, but $320 per hour for other counties he represents and his private practice is about $385 per hour. “So we get about a $100-an-hour discount from this county because he’s our primary attorney,” Ciriello said.
Councilwoman Kimberly Cates said the reason she brought the council having its own attorney up was “just because of current events and it seems that a lot of councils are now hiring their own attorney or having them on some kind of retainer. This has nothing to do with our attorney’s qualifications or his efforts in taking care of us. It just has to do with trying to separate - in case there’s a discrepancy of how something is interpreted or something has been decided. Examples, we’ve had situations where the public have asked us, when was this decided, when was this up. It’s not that we have a difference of opinion currently, but I would like to just explore the possibility of taking some resumes to Alyssa to possibly doing that. So that was my only thought process.”
She also pointed out in Ormsby’s contract, it specifically says if there’s a conflict, he is the commissioners’ attorney “specifically.”
Ciriello said he talked with a couple other attorneys, including Councilman Will Stockdale, and retainers run about $1,000-$1,200 per month on average, depending on which attorney you talk to.
“Warsaw city went through this about four, five years ago about hiring their own attorney to represent the city council in case there’s a conflict between a city attorney and the council themselves, and I think this is what Kim’s getting at, if there’s a conflict between us and the commissioners on an issue. What the city ended up doing, instead of actually putting someone on retainer, they made a motion and passed a motion to allow the council, if that situation were to arrive, to reach out and hire an attorney to deal with that conflict resolution, but they’ve never actually hired an attorney, but they did make it so that they can,” Ciriello recalled.
Cates said several years ago the council had an attorney on retainer and they had a contractual agreement where if the council needed that attorney, they could call that person.
“I don’t foresee that in the near future. I pray that that doesn’t happen, but I believe that we could possibly find someone that would consider doing something like that,” she said, for a fee if they ever needed to call on them.
Wolkins asked if the council needed a resolution to do that and said, “It seems like we’re planning for something that, or solving something, that doesn’t exist right now.”
Ciriello said he wasn’t sure they needed a resolution, but maybe a motion by the council to say that if they got into a situation where they needed their own legal counsel, they could hire a different lawyer than the current county attorney to represent the council’s interest in that conflict.
“Right now, the only conflict that I know that we have with the commissioners and I think major is when it comes to budget time, dipping into their budget, but otherwise I don’t know of any and don’t recall any recent history of conflict with the commissioners,” Ciriello continued.
Cates said, “And another reason that I bring it up is I know that a year, possibly a year and a half ago, there were questions that were posed to our county attorney, and some of us maybe were not comfortable with the answer and we did our own research.”
She said they have had questions come up when the council and commissioners disagreed but “it just wasn’t discussed openly.”
Councilwoman Rachael Rhoades said it would be nice that if the council and commissioners did have a difference of opinion, the council would have its own attorney. She said she spoke with Allen County and they recently moved to having their council attorney, but Whitley County does not.
“If we just have the ability to, if that was ever needed, I don’t know what we would need to do. If it’s just a vote, or if there’s anything else. But, just having the ability in the future,” she said.
Ciriello said the ability to do that would require a motion and a vote by the council. It wouldn’t necessarily mean they would have to take resumes or pay a retainer, the council would just have to make it an option if they so chose.
Councilman Joe Irwin said he thought they should “definitely” do that but he would like to see, without doing resumes or a retainer, a list of possibilities in case it would happen.
“But I’m not willing to spend taxpayer money on a problem we don’t have yet,” he stated.
Council Vice President Kathy Groninger said in her mind, she felt like it was just going to cost the county and taxpayer more money.
“I know in our budget, we have attorney fees in our budget, so in my mind, if we did have a conflict, we’ve already got money in our budget, and, obviously, if we have a conflict, then Ed can’t represent us both, so I think it’s already sort of baked in our budget because we already have money set aside for that, and I think just because we don’t agree with our legal representation, that’s not necessarily a reason to go spend a whole bunch of more money just because a couple of us might disagree with him. That’s where we vote,” she said.
Groninger added it also takes a lot to get up to speed on all the issues, and the county would be paying for the attorney to do that.
Irwin said they just need the ability to have their own attorney if ever there is a conflict.
Cates replied, “I feel like right now we’re kind of like locked in and we really don’t have any options and I just feel like we should allow that to be an option.”
Groninger pointed out the council can’t sign a contract, so she asked if it needed to go through the commissioners first because they’re the ones that would sign a contract. County Auditor Alyssa Schmucker said if the council were going to engage with another attorney other than Ormsby, the commissioners would have to sign the contract.
Stockdale said there’s potential for conflict between what the commissioners and council want, and would be supportive of having a list of attorneys who the council would want to talk to about representation if something were to come up, just to get the ball rolling and not formally engage with an attorney.
Wolkins asked if the council now didn’t have the ability to hire an outside attorney. Ciriello said not without a contract and in order to get a contract, it would have to be approved by the commissioners. Schmucker said all contracts also have to be approved by the county attorney.
Cates said they’re spending $14-$15,000 a year on attorney fees, but hopefully 2027 will be calmer.
Ciriello said it was his opinion they didn’t need to go forward on anything at this time. Groninger said no motion was needed at this time. Irwin said if they need an attorney, they have the ability to do that. Stockdale agreed no action was needed now. Rhoades said it was all good discussion.