Eagle with Stars and Stripes
Continuously serving Kosciusko County since 1854

Community Members Discuss Claypool Elementary At Warsaw School Board

Posted

Community members spoke in favor of keeping Claypool Elementary School open at the Warsaw School Board meeting Monday.
Warsaw Community Schools Superintendent Dr. David Hoffert went over the demographic report and said a lot of it was a repeat from last month’s report. However, he did say there were some different questions that came up in the last few days. He said he was able to sit down with some people and go over some of the demographic shifts.
He provided some upfront statements. WCS is not looking at any teacher layoffs. Any changes would take place with attrition but could require shifts. Official decisions have not been made. Closure of Claypool is a strong possibility, along with shifts in programs and district lines with Harrison and Jefferson. There are state requirements dealing with building capacity and Claypool is under that requirement.
He also went over how the demographics have changed over the years.
Hoffert said enrollment at WCS is 6,541 this year. The high point was about 7,100 in 2014. Since then, Hoffert said birth rates have dropped about 25%. He said WCS is drawing in more students from other school corporations than they’re losing.
Claypool has about 200 students and has a capacity of 38.48%. The largest amount of students Claypool has ever had was about 400 students and has lost an average of about 20 students per year in the last 10 years. Next year, the projected student size will be about 180.
He said there have been attempts to recruit additional students over the last 10 years. Some of the things done include STEM certification to ensure students don’t transfer to other school corporations for those specific opportunities. Specialized classes were put in at Claypool, including Headstart. This summer, WCS received a call from Headstart stating Headstart does not have enough students in the southern part of the county to support the classes any more.
He also discussed district lines, which were put in place in 2009. He said some of the questions he has received were asking if district lines could be changed to help bolster enrollment at Claypool. He said where the true population density is makes it very difficult when it comes to redistricting.
He also said there are service and financial components to demographics.
Hoffert discussed the cost per student at each school. He said when there is a smaller student population, the cost per student goes up. Claypool has the largest cost per student of all WCS schools at $9,048.92. The cost at the high school is $7,809.80. The cost includes salaries and utilities. Financial Stephen Boyer went over changes in the cost per student over the last few years.
Hoffert said it’s not all about dollars and cents. He said when schools start going down on student enrollment, they also start going down in staff members. Currently, he believed there are 12 certified teachers at Claypool. WCS is having a hard time recruiting for the school. Next year, if Claypool continues on, Hoffert said they are looking at reducing one or two teachers. He also talked about other difficulties, such as programming and collaborating between teachers.
As student enrollment gets smaller, Hoffert said it gets to the point where the school corporation is unable to give students equity of education. He said he realizes there are benefits of small class sizes but they’re talking about school size at this point.
Hoffert said decisions on Claypool Elementary will not be made mid-year. Traditionally, these types of decisions are made in late spring.
Board President Heather Reichenbach said as much as they have to celebrate within WCS, this is not a conversation anyone wants to have. She said she appreciates the data because the last thing they want to do is make a decision based on rumors or somebody’s comment and they want to make a decision on actual data.
Board member Randy Polston said this is a very difficult conversation to have and the board has discussed this over several years trying to see if they could get things to turn around and they haven’t.
The board then opened up the meeting to public comments, where nine people spoke.
Andy Airgood, Claypool, asked for the board to help him understand the process that will go on in making a decision.
Hoffert said the conversation traditionally doesn’t start until March or April. A recommendation will be brought to the board, who will then vote on the recommendation. At that point, WCS would work on transition plans for students if Claypool were to close.
Airgood said he knows this is a big decision, but noted only Reichenbach and Polston spoke with any comments after Hoffert’s presentation.
Board member Matt Deuel said this is a conversation that has been going on for years and there have been moments where the board has looked at data for Claypool. WCS has tried to keep moving that number along and maintain it for as long as they can.
“I apologize if the perception is that we don’t have comments or thoughts,” Deuel said, adding it’s been an ongoing conversation and the school board wouldn’t want to do anything to hurt any students. They just find themselves a crossroad to decide what’s best for students.
Dr. Richard Sommers, Silver Lake, said if Claypool is shut down, the school board will be telling people in that area they don’t care about them. He understands the numbers, but he said WCS would be cutting down chances for students if they close the school down.
Heather Helton, Warsaw, said a kid is not a number to her. They’re a heart, soul and mind. They are meaningful. WCS receives about $11,000 per student. When they talked about over $9,000 being spent on students at Claypool, “I say so what?” she said. Those children matter, she said.
Helton said in the administration department, there’s heavy bloat. She suggested taking some of that money and putting it down at the school. She gave several suggestions, including redistricting the school corporation.
Wendy Fitzpatrick, Claypool, talked about the differences her grandchildren had between Claypool and other schools. Her grandchildren had issues at other schools and asked why they couldn’t go back to Claypool. When they went back to Claypool, Fitzpatrick said they haven’t had issues with the children since. Fitzpatrick said the teachers at Claypool care.