Obstruction Charges Dropped Against Shepard

November 8, 2016 at 7:08 p.m.

By Michael [email protected]

Charges against a Mishawaka woman accused of lying to police in connection with a double murder have been dropped.
Ashlyn?Shepard, 22, was charged with one count of obstruction of justice, a level 6 felony.
On Monday in Kosciusko Circuit Court, Kosciusko County Prosecutor Dan Hampton filed a motion to dismiss the charge. Judge Michael Reed approved the motion.
Shepard was charged  with lying to police about Kyle Dehart’s whereabouts during the time of  a double murder in?Syracuse. Dehart is the father of Shepard’s child.
In?February 2015, police found Joshua Knisley dead with a gunshot to the back of the head and Tara Thornburg with a gunshot wound to her head. Thornburg was able to identify Brandon?Woody as the man who shot her and Knisley. She died the next day.
Police arrested Woody, along with his friend, Dehart, who were convicted of the double murder Oct. 7 after a four-day trial. On Oct. 26, Woody was sentenced to 120 years and Dehart to 110 years in prison.
A third man, Thomas Hursey, also believed to be involved in the slayings, is charged with two counts of  murder. Hursey is scheduled for a plea hearing at a later date where he is expected to plead guilty to charges related to the case.  
Shepard originally told police Dehart was with her during the time Thornburg and Knisley were killed. During the trial, she testified she lied to police because she didn’t want her grandmother to know she was out drinking that night.
Hursey testified that while fleeing the scene Dehart tossed his shoes out of the window of the vehicle. Police were able to locate the shoes. Shepard testified she had seen the shoes in?Dehart’s residence. Shepard testified she had not received any promise of leniency in exchange for her testimony.
Hampton said Shepard’s willingness to testify at the trial showed her rehabilitation and acceptance of responsibility in the case, he said in a press release.
“In the end, justice was served with Dehart and Woody’s conviction,” Hampton said in the release.
Dehart’s mother, Joan Dehart, also has been charged in the case.
Joan Dehart faces one charge of assisting a criminal after police said she offered to lie to law enforcement for Woody and Dehart and drove Woody away from her residence.
Joan Dehart’s next court date is a pre–trial conference set for Dec. 5.

Charges against a Mishawaka woman accused of lying to police in connection with a double murder have been dropped.
Ashlyn?Shepard, 22, was charged with one count of obstruction of justice, a level 6 felony.
On Monday in Kosciusko Circuit Court, Kosciusko County Prosecutor Dan Hampton filed a motion to dismiss the charge. Judge Michael Reed approved the motion.
Shepard was charged  with lying to police about Kyle Dehart’s whereabouts during the time of  a double murder in?Syracuse. Dehart is the father of Shepard’s child.
In?February 2015, police found Joshua Knisley dead with a gunshot to the back of the head and Tara Thornburg with a gunshot wound to her head. Thornburg was able to identify Brandon?Woody as the man who shot her and Knisley. She died the next day.
Police arrested Woody, along with his friend, Dehart, who were convicted of the double murder Oct. 7 after a four-day trial. On Oct. 26, Woody was sentenced to 120 years and Dehart to 110 years in prison.
A third man, Thomas Hursey, also believed to be involved in the slayings, is charged with two counts of  murder. Hursey is scheduled for a plea hearing at a later date where he is expected to plead guilty to charges related to the case.  
Shepard originally told police Dehart was with her during the time Thornburg and Knisley were killed. During the trial, she testified she lied to police because she didn’t want her grandmother to know she was out drinking that night.
Hursey testified that while fleeing the scene Dehart tossed his shoes out of the window of the vehicle. Police were able to locate the shoes. Shepard testified she had seen the shoes in?Dehart’s residence. Shepard testified she had not received any promise of leniency in exchange for her testimony.
Hampton said Shepard’s willingness to testify at the trial showed her rehabilitation and acceptance of responsibility in the case, he said in a press release.
“In the end, justice was served with Dehart and Woody’s conviction,” Hampton said in the release.
Dehart’s mother, Joan Dehart, also has been charged in the case.
Joan Dehart faces one charge of assisting a criminal after police said she offered to lie to law enforcement for Woody and Dehart and drove Woody away from her residence.
Joan Dehart’s next court date is a pre–trial conference set for Dec. 5.
Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


Public Occurrences 04.28.25
County Jail Bookings The following people were arrested and booked into the Kosciusko County Jail:

Final Day Of Grace’s Regular Season Full Of History
The final day of the regular season was special for Grace’s baseball team. The Lancers picked up two wins against Bethel with each one representing a historic achievement.

Laurel Jean Mitchell Memorial Bench Unveiled During Ceremony In North Webster
NORTH WEBSTER - Though it’s been 50 years this August that Laurel Jean Mitchell was taken away from her family and friends, she has never been forgotten.

Echoes Of The Past Participate In Plow Day
It was brisk and windy, but the Echoes of the Past members and guests plowed through the weather to enjoy a day at the field owned by Dennis Boggs.

Madeleine M. Fisher
MENTONE – Madeleine M. Fisher, 91, rural Palestine, died Thursday, April 24, 2025, at her residence.