Ybarra Stabbing Trial Set To Begin

July 28, 2016 at 4:25 p.m.

By TIFFANY SHAW, Times-Union Staff Writer-

After a year-long wait and extradition from Texas, David Ybarra is going to trial today for battery with a deadly weapon.

Ybarra, 35, allegedly stabbed a bartender during a fight outside The Post, Pierceton, on Sept. 17, 1995. Ybarra was arrested and released on bond, then fled to Donna, Texas. His original trial was scheduled for March 17, 1997, but he did not return.

The Kosciusko County Sheriff's Department reported they had Ybarra in custody on March 4 and Kosciusko Superior Court scheduled the trial for today.

Jury selection was held this morning, and deputy prosecutor Byron Tinkey said he would be "surprised" if there was trouble finding a jury from the 32-person pool.

Ybarra is charged with battery, a Class C felony, for allegedly stabbing Greg Alfano.

Two bartenders, Bill King and Alfano, reportedly went outside the front entrance of The Post to break up a fight. Both men were stabbed, Alfano in the back and King in the shoulder, and required treatment at Kosciusko Community Hospital. According to police reports, the fight started earlier inside The Post and continued when the participants were told to leave the bar.

A Pierceton Police Department officer later reported there were approximately 20 people involved in the fight, with as many people standing around the action shouting. The deputy was forced to use pepper spray to stop the fight.

The officer reported he was on routine patrol driving down a nearby alley when he saw a man staggering down the alley. As he drove closer, he saw blood on the man's back and called for an ambulance.

Tinkey said Alfano is expected to testify today that he entered the fight and was holding one man to stop him when Alfano was stabbed in the back. Alfano allegedly turned around and saw the man with the knife, later identified as Ybarra. Alfano then ran down the alley where he found Jeff Larsen.

While Alfano was being treated in the ambulance, police brought a man up to the ambulance for Alfano to see.

Alfano reportedly "immediately and positively (identified) him," Tinkey said. The man was allegedly identified as Ybarra.

"I think the testimony (will be) really strong," Tinkey said of the upcoming trial.

Tinkey said the prosecution is planning to call a witness who allegedly admitted to stabbing King. The witness also reportedly told police he gave Ybarra a knife and later the two allegedly hid it after the altercation. [[In-content Ad]]

After a year-long wait and extradition from Texas, David Ybarra is going to trial today for battery with a deadly weapon.

Ybarra, 35, allegedly stabbed a bartender during a fight outside The Post, Pierceton, on Sept. 17, 1995. Ybarra was arrested and released on bond, then fled to Donna, Texas. His original trial was scheduled for March 17, 1997, but he did not return.

The Kosciusko County Sheriff's Department reported they had Ybarra in custody on March 4 and Kosciusko Superior Court scheduled the trial for today.

Jury selection was held this morning, and deputy prosecutor Byron Tinkey said he would be "surprised" if there was trouble finding a jury from the 32-person pool.

Ybarra is charged with battery, a Class C felony, for allegedly stabbing Greg Alfano.

Two bartenders, Bill King and Alfano, reportedly went outside the front entrance of The Post to break up a fight. Both men were stabbed, Alfano in the back and King in the shoulder, and required treatment at Kosciusko Community Hospital. According to police reports, the fight started earlier inside The Post and continued when the participants were told to leave the bar.

A Pierceton Police Department officer later reported there were approximately 20 people involved in the fight, with as many people standing around the action shouting. The deputy was forced to use pepper spray to stop the fight.

The officer reported he was on routine patrol driving down a nearby alley when he saw a man staggering down the alley. As he drove closer, he saw blood on the man's back and called for an ambulance.

Tinkey said Alfano is expected to testify today that he entered the fight and was holding one man to stop him when Alfano was stabbed in the back. Alfano allegedly turned around and saw the man with the knife, later identified as Ybarra. Alfano then ran down the alley where he found Jeff Larsen.

While Alfano was being treated in the ambulance, police brought a man up to the ambulance for Alfano to see.

Alfano reportedly "immediately and positively (identified) him," Tinkey said. The man was allegedly identified as Ybarra.

"I think the testimony (will be) really strong," Tinkey said of the upcoming trial.

Tinkey said the prosecution is planning to call a witness who allegedly admitted to stabbing King. The witness also reportedly told police he gave Ybarra a knife and later the two allegedly hid it after the altercation. [[In-content Ad]]

Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


The Penalty Box: Bears Need To Pick A Site And Start Digging
Everything about the Chicago Bears feels like they’re trending upward.

Winona Lake Zoning
Poage

vacation of Public Way
Clevenger

Public Occurrences 05.14.25
County Jail Bookings The following people were arrested and booked into the Kosciusko County Jail:

Fat & Skinny Tire Festival’s 20th Year Feels Surreal To Co-Founder
WINONA LAKE - For Fat & Skinny Tire Fest co-founder and co-director Greg Demopoulos, the fact that this weekend is the 20th year for the three-day bicycling event is surreal.