No Formal Charges Yet In Triple Fatal Accident

July 28, 2016 at 4:25 p.m.

By TIFFANY SHAW, Times-Union Staff Writer-

Formal charges have not been filed yet against Brandon J. Robinson, the Warsaw teenager who was allegedly driving a pickup that struck a car, killing three people.

Robinson, 18, was booked into Kosciusko County Jail Friday night on three charges of driving while intoxicated causing death, three Class C felonies. Two of his passengers in the pickup were booked into jail on charges of possession/consumption of alcohol by a minor.

More charges could be filed when the official paperwork is given to Kosciusko County Prosecutor David Kolbe.

Investigators from the Warsaw Police Department met with two members of the prosecutor's office Monday to discuss the case.

The police said they are still working on the investigation, including a reconstruction of the accident.

Robinson is accused of drinking several beers before driving his pickup into Warsaw Friday night. He allegedly ran the stop sign at the intersection of Zimmer and Crystal Lake roads and struck a car driven by Aaron P. Hatfield, 17.

Hatfield was pronounced dead at the scene along with a backseat passenger, Tyler Bartley, 12. Hatfield's girlfriend, Heather Florey, 16, the front-seat passenger was pronounced dead later at Kosciusko Community Hospital.

The two other passengers in the car, Tiffany Bartley, 13, and Monica Hatfield, 6 months, were airlifted to Parkview Memorial Hospital, Fort Wayne, where they are listed in serious condition.

All five people in the car were from Claypool.

Donald Ditton, 19, one of Robinson's passengers, was booked into Kosciusko County Jail on the illegal consumption charge. He was released on $175 bond.

Another passenger, Phillip Gagnon, 20, allegedly fled the accident scene on foot but was later arrested at his home. He was also released from jail on bond.

Warsaw Police Chief Craig Allebach said that his department received guidance from the prosecutor's office in preparing the paperwork against Robinson.

A memo at the Kosciusko County Sheriff's Department cautioned jailers and deputies to allow only visitors that Robinson requested to see him during visitation because threats were allegedly made against him. The memo also requested extra security in the courtroom during Robinson's appearances, asking that those who enter the courtroom be checked for possible weapons.

Allebach said police were waiting for results of drug screenings and checking the brakes of the pickup. He said he hopes to file the charges later today or early tomorrow.

The delay is caused by the fact he wants to make sure all the evidence is in so all the charges can be filed at once, Allebach said.

If the charges are filed today, Robinson could make his initial court appearance Thursday. [[In-content Ad]]

Formal charges have not been filed yet against Brandon J. Robinson, the Warsaw teenager who was allegedly driving a pickup that struck a car, killing three people.

Robinson, 18, was booked into Kosciusko County Jail Friday night on three charges of driving while intoxicated causing death, three Class C felonies. Two of his passengers in the pickup were booked into jail on charges of possession/consumption of alcohol by a minor.

More charges could be filed when the official paperwork is given to Kosciusko County Prosecutor David Kolbe.

Investigators from the Warsaw Police Department met with two members of the prosecutor's office Monday to discuss the case.

The police said they are still working on the investigation, including a reconstruction of the accident.

Robinson is accused of drinking several beers before driving his pickup into Warsaw Friday night. He allegedly ran the stop sign at the intersection of Zimmer and Crystal Lake roads and struck a car driven by Aaron P. Hatfield, 17.

Hatfield was pronounced dead at the scene along with a backseat passenger, Tyler Bartley, 12. Hatfield's girlfriend, Heather Florey, 16, the front-seat passenger was pronounced dead later at Kosciusko Community Hospital.

The two other passengers in the car, Tiffany Bartley, 13, and Monica Hatfield, 6 months, were airlifted to Parkview Memorial Hospital, Fort Wayne, where they are listed in serious condition.

All five people in the car were from Claypool.

Donald Ditton, 19, one of Robinson's passengers, was booked into Kosciusko County Jail on the illegal consumption charge. He was released on $175 bond.

Another passenger, Phillip Gagnon, 20, allegedly fled the accident scene on foot but was later arrested at his home. He was also released from jail on bond.

Warsaw Police Chief Craig Allebach said that his department received guidance from the prosecutor's office in preparing the paperwork against Robinson.

A memo at the Kosciusko County Sheriff's Department cautioned jailers and deputies to allow only visitors that Robinson requested to see him during visitation because threats were allegedly made against him. The memo also requested extra security in the courtroom during Robinson's appearances, asking that those who enter the courtroom be checked for possible weapons.

Allebach said police were waiting for results of drug screenings and checking the brakes of the pickup. He said he hopes to file the charges later today or early tomorrow.

The delay is caused by the fact he wants to make sure all the evidence is in so all the charges can be filed at once, Allebach said.

If the charges are filed today, Robinson could make his initial court appearance Thursday. [[In-content Ad]]

Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


Wawasee Community School Corporation Reorganizes, Announces Restructuring Plan To Protect Classrooms, Streamline Operations
SYRACUSE – In response to projected budget reductions for the 2025–26 school year, Wawasee Community School Corporation (WCSC) is implementing a strategic restructuring plan that prioritizes classrooms, safeguards educational quality and streamlines district operations.

The Penalty Box: Bears Need To Pick A Site And Start Digging
Everything about the Chicago Bears feels like they’re trending upward.

Winona Lake Zoning
Poage

vacation of Public Way
Clevenger

Public Occurrences 05.14.25
County Jail Bookings The following people were arrested and booked into the Kosciusko County Jail: