Milford Man Found Not Guilty In Bomb Threat Case

July 28, 2016 at 4:25 p.m.

By KRISTA PRIMROSE, Times-Union Staff Writer-

A Milford man was acquitted Wednesday of making bomb threats and criminal mischief by a six-person jury.

Nathan J. Weldy, 27, was accused of calling bomb threats to Parker-Goshen, Syracuse, his employer, on Halloween night 2000.

Weldy was suspected of the calls when the receptionist used the *-69 feature on the telephone to identify the last caller. The number returned to Weldy's brother-in-law's telephone, which was listed as Weldy's contact number. Weldy had no home telephone at the time.

Police arrested Weldy the same night and obtained a confession. Weldy and his lawyer, David Kolbe, say the confession was coerced.

According to testimony, Weldy was interrogated by an officer who used vulagarity. The officer was "very intimidating," Weldy said. Weldy also was denied a lawyer or pastor's counsel, though he says he requested it up to five times.

During questioning, Weldy said he was led to believe that if he confessed, he could post a $100 bond and go home to his family. At about 1 a.m. Nov. 1, Weldy confessed to the crimes, saying he did it as a Halloween prank.

He was arrested and formerly charged Nov. 8, 2003, with false informing of a bomb threat and criminal mischief.

According to court documents, compelling evidence against Weldy was primarily composed of the telephone trace and confession.

Testimony given in court said the telephone trace was faulty because Parker-Goshen operates a multi-line telephone system. Incoming calls cannot be traced back to particular lines using *-69, and Weldy had legitimate reasons to call the business that day. The *-69 trace could have picked up his calls to other lines in the business on Halloween.

The four-man, two-woman jury deliberated from 9:46 a.m. to 1:36 p.m. before returning with a verdict of not guilty on all charges. [[In-content Ad]]

A Milford man was acquitted Wednesday of making bomb threats and criminal mischief by a six-person jury.

Nathan J. Weldy, 27, was accused of calling bomb threats to Parker-Goshen, Syracuse, his employer, on Halloween night 2000.

Weldy was suspected of the calls when the receptionist used the *-69 feature on the telephone to identify the last caller. The number returned to Weldy's brother-in-law's telephone, which was listed as Weldy's contact number. Weldy had no home telephone at the time.

Police arrested Weldy the same night and obtained a confession. Weldy and his lawyer, David Kolbe, say the confession was coerced.

According to testimony, Weldy was interrogated by an officer who used vulagarity. The officer was "very intimidating," Weldy said. Weldy also was denied a lawyer or pastor's counsel, though he says he requested it up to five times.

During questioning, Weldy said he was led to believe that if he confessed, he could post a $100 bond and go home to his family. At about 1 a.m. Nov. 1, Weldy confessed to the crimes, saying he did it as a Halloween prank.

He was arrested and formerly charged Nov. 8, 2003, with false informing of a bomb threat and criminal mischief.

According to court documents, compelling evidence against Weldy was primarily composed of the telephone trace and confession.

Testimony given in court said the telephone trace was faulty because Parker-Goshen operates a multi-line telephone system. Incoming calls cannot be traced back to particular lines using *-69, and Weldy had legitimate reasons to call the business that day. The *-69 trace could have picked up his calls to other lines in the business on Halloween.

The four-man, two-woman jury deliberated from 9:46 a.m. to 1:36 p.m. before returning with a verdict of not guilty on all charges. [[In-content Ad]]

Have a news tip? Email [email protected] or Call/Text 360-922-3092

e-Edition


e-edition

Sign up


for our email newsletters

Weekly Top Stories

Sign up to get our top stories delivered to your inbox every Sunday

Daily Updates & Breaking News Alerts

Sign up to get our daily updates and breaking news alerts delivered to your inbox daily

Latest Stories


Fat & Skinny Tire Festival’s 20th Year Feels Surreal To Co-Founder
WINONA LAKE - For Fat & Skinny Tire Fest co-founder and co-director Greg Demopoulos, the fact that this weekend is the 20th year for the three-day bicycling event is surreal.

Nappanee Man Injured In Turkey Hunting Accident In Fulton County
A Nappanee man was injured in a turkey hunting accident Saturday in Fulton County.

Breakfast Optimist Club Car Show Is Sunday
Warsaw Breakfast Optimist Club is hosting the 15th Annual City of Lakes Car Show on Sunday, May 18 from noon to 5 p.m. in downtown Warsaw at the courthouse square.

Huntington Teen Arrested On Rape, Child Molesting Charges
A Huntington teen was arrested after allegedly forcing a minor under 14 to have sex.

Attorney General Rokita Sounds The Alarm On Fake TxTag Emails That Target Hoosiers’ Wallets
Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita is alerting Hoosiers to a surge in spam emails falsely claiming to be from State of Indiana departments regarding TxTag, the Texas toll collection system.