Madison Fowler and Stephen Cartwright are pictured. Photo from website
Madison Fowler and Stephen Cartwright are pictured. Photo from website

Two people wanted in connection to a July homicide in Indianapolis were arrested Thursday in Warsaw.

According to a news release Friday from the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department, 42-year-old Stephen Cartwright and 21-year-old Madison Fowler were arrested for their alleged involvement in a July homicide investigation.

An Indianapolis Star story reports they were arrested Thursday in Warsaw. Cartwright was preliminary charged with murder, and Fowler was preliminary charged with armed robbery and murder.

Just after 7 a.m. July 3, IMPD Northwest District officers were dispatched to the 7000 block of Bretton Wood Drive on a report of a person shot, the release states. Officers arrived and found 31-year-old Medhat Saad outside. He suffered injuries consistent with a gunshot wound(s), the release states. Indianapolis Emergency Medical Services arrived, and Saad was pronounced dead at the scene.

IMPD homicide detectives responded to the scene and began their investigation. As the investigation continued, the release states, detectives were able to identify Cartwright and Fowler as the suspects.

The Indianapolis Star says the suspects were captured on a Ring Video Doorbell during the fatal shooting. Video footage shows the woman - later identified as Fowler - walk up to the front porch of the home, push a button to activate the doorbell, then look into the camera and ask for a pitcher of water. She stated her car overheated.

The sound of the door being unlocked was captured by the camera, then Fowler moved out of the direct path of the door, the Indianapolis Star says the probable cause affidavit for Cartwright states. As it was being unlocked, Cartwright is seen approaching and pointing a firearm at the door. He pulled the trigger of the firearm and a bullet shattered glass on the door. The video captured him attempting to get the door open, then firing the weapon again. It also captured a distinct tattoo on his forearm. Cartwright noticed the doorbell camera, ducks his head, covers his face and then knocks the camera off the wall, according to the Indianapolis Star.

In an interview with a detective after the video and social media led police to Cartwright and Fowler, Fowler allegedly identified the woman and man from the doorbell video as herself and Cartwright, the Indianapolis Star reports. Fowler said they received information there was a substantial amount of money in the home and decided they were going to rob the homeowner.

Saad’s father was woken up by his son calling for help and then Cartwright coming upstairs and kicking in his bedroom door. Saad’s father was not hurt in the robbery, and after waiting for the intruders to leave, the father found his son downstairs bleeding on the floor. The father then ran next door to call for help.

The Indianapolis Star reported the father’s cell phone was stolen, turned off after the shooting, then turned back on in Greenwood and then again in Warsaw.

“Thanks to the outstanding work by the Warsaw Police Department, Indianapolis Violent Crimes Unit and Indiana State Police, both suspects were apprehended without further incident in Warsaw. Cartwright and Fowler were arrested for murder,” the IMPD release states.

Captain Brad Kellar, WPD public information officer, said Sunday evening that WPD was contacted by IMPD Thursday morning requesting assistance in their homicide investigation from the beginning of July.  They believed two suspects resided in the Warsaw area.  

Based on their preliminary investigation, two possible locations were believed to be where they were staying, Kellar said. With this initial information, WPD began adding to the investigation, using Warsaw’s patrol and detective divisions, along with NET 43. WPD was able to assist with surveillance, drone operations and digital forensics. Surveillance confirmed both suspects were at 1413 E. Wooster Road, Winona Lake, Kellar said. Officers converged on the residence and both suspects were taken into custody without incident.

After conducting interviews at WPD, Indianapolis investigators secured a search warrant through Marion County for 309 S. High St., Warsaw, where several subjects were originally detained. No other arrests were made in connection with the homicide investigation. However, additional evidence was seized and there was an unrelated arrest of an adult female for a local misdemeanor warrant, according to Kellar. The Kosciusko County Sheriff’s Office assisted on the execution of that search warrant.

IMPD detectives took custody of a man and woman and transported them back to Indianapolis upon conclusion of their investigation here in Warsaw Thursday night.

Fowler previously was arrested and booked into the Kosciusko County Jail on May 22, 2022, for unauthorized entry of a motor vehicle. Her address was listed then as Milford.

Cartwright, of Greenwood, is facing a Level 6 felony charge of theft in Kosciusko County for allegedly trying to steal a boat around June 21, 2022, valued at between $750 and $50,000.

Anyone with information about the July 3 shooting should contact IMPD Det. Brad Nuetzman at the Homicide Office at 317-327-3475 or email him at Alternatively, they can call Crime Stoppers of Central Indiana at 317-262-8477 (TIPS) to remain anonymous.